Technically, this wasn't another
two-horror movie weekend, in the sense that
Sorority Row opened last week. But since I didn't get to see it until yesterday, the same day I saw
Jennifer's Body, that's how it worked out. And it was thematically appropriate, too, as both films had sort of an 80s throwback feel to them.
And since everything was better in the 80s, that means they were great, right? Well...
Spoilers follow...Sorority RowThe killer's motivation (and by extension, the whole movie) is ridiculous, and if you haven't figured out who it is by the halfway point at the very latest, this is either your first horror film or you might be functionally retarded. But like most slasher films,
Sorority Row is more about the journey than the destination.
And most of the journey is actually a lot of fun. During it, you get to see (in no particular order) Audrina Partridge get brutally murdered, Carrie Fisher wield a shotgun, one co-ed get her face melted off with a flare gun, another co-ed get most a bottle shoved down her throat, and the lug wrench joining the pantheon of tools that can also serve as potential murder weapons. But there was lots of room for improvement.
Let's start with--as always--the gore. If it wasn't for the occasional flash of nudity and liberal use of the word "fuck," I'd swear this was a PG-13 film. They really could have amped it up a bit here. Or in the very least, shown that melting face for more than a quick second.
Then there were the characters. You don't go into a movie like this expecting deep characterization, but they really didn't even try. About the only interesting one is Chugs, and she's the first killed off. There is one moment at the end, when Andy is trying to convince Cassidy to help him finish off the rest of the girls, that I actually thought she might say yes, and the movie would have had one of the unexpectedly all-time great endings. But of course, in the end, the film sticks to the formula to the letter.
About Andy. So all this was to keep anyone from telling what Cassidy did? It never occurred to him that a bunch of dead co-eds might get people asking questions? And he just happened to be lurking in the sorority house bathroom--in full killer costume, no less--without anyone noticing, so that he could whack that one girl who was in the wrong shower stall at the wrong time? That scene makes so little sense that I wonder if they finished the movie and realized that for a horror movie called
Sorority Row, they hadn't shown a single pair of breasts, and quickly cobbled it together.
In the end, I'll keep going to movies like
Sorority Row because the slasher film is a dying art form, and I'd like to see some director make one that's as good as those from the glory days of the 80s. It probably won't happen, but hope springs eternal.
Script: C+
Acting: C
Gore: B-
Overall: C+
Jennifer's BodyTo the extent that it's possible to feel sorry for a horror movie, I feel sorry for
Jennifer's Body. It's a perfectly adequately-made film, and really, there's nothing to dislike about it, per se, except that it's the unfortunate victim of its own hype. Between it being Megan Fox's first starring role, and Diablo Cody's improbable follow-up to
Juno, it almost feels like it should one of those rare horror films that transcends the genre (due a lot more to Cody's involvement than Fox's). It doesn't. It doesn't even come close, so it feels like a bit of a let-down.
But based on its own merits, it's not a bad film. Good plot, good acting, and several tense moments. The real problem is the dialogue. The cleverest exchange was given away in the trailer ("Jennifer's evil." "I know." "No. I mean, she's actually evil. Not high school evil."), and nothing else really got much of a reaction. It wasn't quite as
Juno-esque as I'd feared, but it also wasn't especially distinctive. The closest parallel I can think of is the dialogue
From Dusk Till Dawn, which was obviously Tarantino, but wasn't in-your-face about it.
For some reason, this is coming off more negative than I intended.
Jennifer's Body is a pretty good horror film. But if you go in expecting anything more than that, you're going to be disappointed.
One more thing: During the scene where Megan Fox and Amanda Seyfried are making out, the woman sitting behind me whispered, "Ew!" disgustedly. This was not my reaction. Men and women are different.
Script: B
Acting: B+
Gore: C+
Overall: B
Well, this has been another fun look at recent horror films! Next month:
Zombieland and
Saw VI! Should be fun! And...what's that? There's one more film to review today? What are you talking about? What other...oh, come on. Really?
The Twilight Saga: New Moon (trailer)Sigh. Okay.
Look, normally, I'm a live-and-let-live kind of guy, you know? Certainly, people could give me shit over my love of fantasy football and comic books and so on, so I try not to judge. But I had to sit through the trailer for this fucking movie before both
Sorority Row and
Jennifer's Body, and I'll no doubt have to sit through it every other time I see a movie from now until November 20th. And it's
terrible. I mean, not only does it give away the entire story (such as it is), but I don't see how anyone other than a 13 year-old girl can see this and think, "Yay!"
Here's a recap of the trailer: The whiny pale girl and the whiny pale vampire break up, there are shirtless dudes, the girl decides to pretend to kill herself, the vampire decides to kill himself for real (with his shirt off, naturally), more shirtless dudes, and Dakota Fanning throws away what up until now has been a fairly dignified career.
Now, I'm not bashing this indiscriminately. I watched the first movie. I didn't think it was terrible. I certainly didn't think it was
good, but I didn't want to break the DVD in half or anything. But that was before
Twilight fever gripped the nation, and I started seeing Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart on the cover of every single magazine at one point or another.
Also, someone told me what happens in the fourth book, and you know what? That's some fucked up shit for a young adult novel.
I hate
Twilight. You should, too.
Script: F
Acting: F
Gore: F
Overall: F