Nothing says "winner" quite like being home on a Saturday night watching the new movie on HBO, yet that's where I found myself last night.
Just Like Heaven was the movie, and although it has one of the most completely and utterly ludicrous plots ever (Reese Witherspoon stars as a woman who's never had a relationship or, apparently, even a date. Oh, and there's something about her coming back as a spirit that only Mark Ruffalo can see and hear, and Napoleon Dynamite plays a psychic or something, but in terms of believability, both of those pale in comparison to the first thing), I actually dug it. And as I watched, I realized something.
I really like romantic comedies. In fact, I've probably seen more romantic comedies than movies of any other genre, aside from horror.
Just like horror films, though, for every good romantic comedy, there are something like twenty really bad ones. So for no particular reason, here's my list of the five best and worst romantic comedies of all time, from a guy's point of view.
Best:
5) While You Were Sleeping
Remember that brief window in the 90s when Sandra Bullock was really cute and charming? I think it stretched from Speed to...well, Speed 2. Anyway, during that time, she managed to squeeze in this film, which is actually even more contrived than Just Like Heaven, but works in spite of itself.
4) Shakespeare in Love
Unfairly maligned as the most undeserved Best Picture winner in recent memory (*cough*, *cough*, Gladiator, *cough*), the movie is actually really good, so long as you don't take things like Shakespeare or history too seriously. And when you consider that it manages to be really good in spite of Gwyneth Paltrow, you realize that it's even better. Because Gwyneth Paltrow usually makes everything suck.
3) There's Something About Mary
Not only is this arguably one of the most hilarious movies ever made, but it proved that under the right circumstances, stalking can be adorable.
2) The American President
This is why I don't believe it when I hear people whine about how hard dating is in DC. If the President of the United States can do it, so can you.
1) Notting Hill
As best I can tell, there are only two men on Earth who really love this movie: me and Hugh Grant. And I'm not even sure about him. Regardless, not only is it my favorite romantic comedy, but one of my favorite movies in general. Just a really beautiful, wonderfully made film all around.
Worst:
5) You've Got Mail
Meg Ryan is a small bookstore owner. Tom Hanks goes around opening big box bookstores, putting people like her out of business. At first, they hate each other, then find out that they've been secretly having cybersex or something. At no point does a safe fall on either of them, to the detriment of the film.
4) When Harry Met Sally
There's something about Meg Ryan that doesn't gel with comedies, romantic or otherwise. I've never seen Sleepless in Seattle, but if I had, I'm sure I'd hate that one, too. Anyway, it's bad enough how lame this movie is, but the fact that it's so completely overrated is even worse.
3) Serendipity
John Cusak and Kate Beckensale have one of those only-in-the-movies love at first sight moments. But instead of just counting their blessings, she makes the poor bastard jump through hoops to prove that fate wants them together. Then they get separated (before exchanging contact info, naturally), and don't see each other for years. In the meantime, Cusack's character gets engaged to Bridget Moynahan, who's one of the few women on Earth who completely blows Beckensale out of the water in terms of looks. Then he leaves her. Wha...?
2) America's Sweethearts
Billy Crystal got a bunch of his movie star friends together and managed to make one of the most unromantic, uncomedic romantic comedies in the history of cinema. In fact, the only alleged romantic comedy worse than this is...
1) What Women Want
Crap, crap, crap. Two hours of Mel Gibson getting in touch with his feminine side, and pretending that Helen Hunt is funny and attractive, despite there being demonstrable evidence to the contrary. Personally, I suspect his alcoholism and crazed anti-Semitic outburst were simply caused by post-traumatic stress of having made this film.